In the movie Mean Girls we can see two Queer Theory stereotypes, these are
the characters Damien and Janice. They play opposing roles, as Damien is much
more feminine than Janice who in terms of Damien is much more masculine. Damien
can be considered this type of a queen homosexual, because he acts in a
feministic way and can also be considered a drama queen at times. This
stereotype can be assigned to him because of his body language. This doesn't
mean that he acts just like a female but you can see, feminine characteristics
in the way that he walks, moves and gestures. Also, the way that he talks could
connote that he is more of a feminine character, this is because his voice is
much higher than any other male characters which are shown. Moreover, if
comparing him to any other male characters, they are much more attractive than
him which strengthens the stereotype, as he is different than all the other
males. Another thing that makes him more feminine is the way that he acted when
he and Janice took Cady through the corridors, he was protective in some way
shouting to everyone to move out of the way, just like a mother figure.
Furthermore, he is carelessly staying in girls toilets, just like he would feel
that he belongs there, and while being in the toilet we learn that he has pink
clothes. This is especially weird and unexpected because the two girls with
which he talks to, don't own any pink clothes. The last aspect that I think
makes him this type of homosexual guy is the way in which he reacted when
Janice and him started to talk to Cady. The first part of her that he saw and
taken into consideration was her hair; the colour of it. I suppose that it is
very rare for a man to notice the women hair and say that they want exactly the
same colour.
On the other hand, Janice is much more masculine and aggressive character. We can see this especially when someone walks next to Janice and makes a rude comment about her hair, and she, instead of feeling humiliated talks back at him. Moreover, we can see her mostly in black clothing, this could connote that she rebels against some kind of idea about people being considered in the same way where they should really be seen individually to who they really are. This clothing makes her stand out from the crowd and convey this idea that everyone is different. Also, the way she wears her clothes; she is nearly always covered from top to bottom by the clothes, which is not rally considered to be a feminine way to wear something, especially if we have a comparison. She can be compared with the so called 'plastics' which were shown wearing their sports kit in a very feminine way, with most of the legs showing and tops so short that you can see the belly. This is considered to be more feminine way of wearing clothes in that movie, than how Janice wears her clothes. The last aspect that makes Janice that kind of a soft butch is her hair. This is because they are black and she always wears them tied up, whereas 'plastics' have this rule to wear the hair tied up only once a week. This looks like, they would want to keep their feminine status by having their hair loose most of the time rather than look tie their hair back and look like guys without anything on their heads. These stereotypes would consider all the homosexuals to act in this way, whereas some will be more masculine or feminine regardless of their gender.
I don’t suppose that these stereotypes are used correctly, this is because not all homosexual people behave this way, just because some are more masculine or feminine, it doesn’t mean that their behaviour is exactly the same as it was portrayed in that movie. Although, I don’t think that these stereotypes are used entirely correctly they were added into the movie for a specific reason. This is because people like to laugh at situations or people which behave differently, and not meaning this in a bad way, it is funny to see a guy which is excited about the colour of someone’s hair or a girl which is sassier than guys. But I think that the use of these stereotypes was essential in this movie, otherwise it would be just another teenage problems movie, which isn’t really interesting but, if the characters are portrayed in a different way than they would be shown usually then the whole storyline is much more interesting, like it was seen in this film. So even if the film is showing stereotypical behaviour of homosexuals, I wouldn’t change anything in the way they were portrayed. This is because it made the film really funny and worth watching, whereas if it was just about the life of normal teenagers and their problems then it would be really boring.
I have looked at one of Queer Theorists, Judith Butler. She has written a book Gender Trouble in 1990, where she talked about feminism and how women are wrongly seen in the community as a group that has common characteristics and interests. She argues that there is no clear line that separates the characters or behaviours of men and women. All of them have their own individual identity. She also, says that feminists reject the idea of biology to be the destiny of each person. But as the patriarchal culture developed, it left no choice for males and females but to live according with the socially accepted behaviours. Butler prefers the idea of gender being something that varies from one person to another and there are no set similarities between them. And she argues that the only reason that people can say that they feel more like a man or a woman is because of the cultural identity which set some kind of standards for both of the genders. But in the movie Mean Girls, these standard boundaries are extremely violated. First of by Damien which behaves more like a woman should with his pink shirts, walking into girls bathroom, being the only man on the meeting which only the girls had to say sorry to each other and by simply his feminine behaviour. The second example is Janice which behaves in a more masculine way as she wears mostly black and the clothes cover her nearly from top to bottom, not like the other girls which wear skirts or t-shirts. Also, by her sassiness to other people, and there are no other girls shown which behave like this.
On the other hand, Janice is much more masculine and aggressive character. We can see this especially when someone walks next to Janice and makes a rude comment about her hair, and she, instead of feeling humiliated talks back at him. Moreover, we can see her mostly in black clothing, this could connote that she rebels against some kind of idea about people being considered in the same way where they should really be seen individually to who they really are. This clothing makes her stand out from the crowd and convey this idea that everyone is different. Also, the way she wears her clothes; she is nearly always covered from top to bottom by the clothes, which is not rally considered to be a feminine way to wear something, especially if we have a comparison. She can be compared with the so called 'plastics' which were shown wearing their sports kit in a very feminine way, with most of the legs showing and tops so short that you can see the belly. This is considered to be more feminine way of wearing clothes in that movie, than how Janice wears her clothes. The last aspect that makes Janice that kind of a soft butch is her hair. This is because they are black and she always wears them tied up, whereas 'plastics' have this rule to wear the hair tied up only once a week. This looks like, they would want to keep their feminine status by having their hair loose most of the time rather than look tie their hair back and look like guys without anything on their heads. These stereotypes would consider all the homosexuals to act in this way, whereas some will be more masculine or feminine regardless of their gender.
I don’t suppose that these stereotypes are used correctly, this is because not all homosexual people behave this way, just because some are more masculine or feminine, it doesn’t mean that their behaviour is exactly the same as it was portrayed in that movie. Although, I don’t think that these stereotypes are used entirely correctly they were added into the movie for a specific reason. This is because people like to laugh at situations or people which behave differently, and not meaning this in a bad way, it is funny to see a guy which is excited about the colour of someone’s hair or a girl which is sassier than guys. But I think that the use of these stereotypes was essential in this movie, otherwise it would be just another teenage problems movie, which isn’t really interesting but, if the characters are portrayed in a different way than they would be shown usually then the whole storyline is much more interesting, like it was seen in this film. So even if the film is showing stereotypical behaviour of homosexuals, I wouldn’t change anything in the way they were portrayed. This is because it made the film really funny and worth watching, whereas if it was just about the life of normal teenagers and their problems then it would be really boring.
I have looked at one of Queer Theorists, Judith Butler. She has written a book Gender Trouble in 1990, where she talked about feminism and how women are wrongly seen in the community as a group that has common characteristics and interests. She argues that there is no clear line that separates the characters or behaviours of men and women. All of them have their own individual identity. She also, says that feminists reject the idea of biology to be the destiny of each person. But as the patriarchal culture developed, it left no choice for males and females but to live according with the socially accepted behaviours. Butler prefers the idea of gender being something that varies from one person to another and there are no set similarities between them. And she argues that the only reason that people can say that they feel more like a man or a woman is because of the cultural identity which set some kind of standards for both of the genders. But in the movie Mean Girls, these standard boundaries are extremely violated. First of by Damien which behaves more like a woman should with his pink shirts, walking into girls bathroom, being the only man on the meeting which only the girls had to say sorry to each other and by simply his feminine behaviour. The second example is Janice which behaves in a more masculine way as she wears mostly black and the clothes cover her nearly from top to bottom, not like the other girls which wear skirts or t-shirts. Also, by her sassiness to other people, and there are no other girls shown which behave like this.